Course Homepage Preface On Learning
Build Your Intuition
1. 1-Minute Summary 2. X-Ray Vision 3. 3d Intuition
Learn The Lingo
4. Integrals, Derivatives 5. Computer Notation
Basic Understanding
6. Improved Algebra 7. Linear Changes 8. Squared Changes
Deeper Understanding
9. Infinity 10. Derivatives 11. Fundamental Theorem
Figure Out The Rules
12. Add, Multiply, Invert 13. Patterns In The Rules 14. Take Powers, Divide
Put It To Use
15. Archimedes' Formulas Summary
Feedback
Welcome to an intuition-first calculus course.
Read online, or buy the complete edition for videos, PDF, and discussion.
8 min read

13. Patterns In The Rules

We've uncovered the first few rules of calculus:

$$(f + g)' = f' + g' $$ $$(f \cdot g)' = f \cdot g' + g \cdot f' $$ $$\left( \frac{1}{x} \right)' = - \frac{1}{x^2} $$

Instead of blasting through more rules, step back. Is there a pattern here?

Combining Perspectives

Imagine a function as a business with interacting departments, or a machine with interconnected parts. What happens when we make a change?

If our business has 4 departments, there are 4 perspectives to account for. It sounds painfully simple when written out: count the changes coming from each part!

No matter the specific interaction between parts F and G (addition, subtraction, multiplication, exponents...), we just have two perspectives to consider:

Wolfram Alpha

Aha! That's why the rules for $$$(f + g)'$$$ and $$$(f \cdot g)'$$$ are two added perspectives. The derivative of $$$\frac{1}{X}$$$ has a perspective because there's just one "moving part", x. (If you like, there is a contribution from "1" about the change it experiences: nothing. No matter how much you yell, 1 stays 1.)

The exact contribution from a perspective depends on the interaction:

You might forget the exact form of the multiplication rule. But you can think "The derivative of $$$f \cdot g$$$ must be something with $$$df$$$ + something with $$$dg$$$."

Let's go further: what about the derivative of $$$a \cdot b + c$$$? You guessed it, 3 perspectives that should be added: something involving $$$da$$$ plus something involving $$$db$$$ plus something involving $$$dc$$$.

We can predict the shape of derivatives for gnarly equations. What's the derivative of:

$$x^y \cdot \frac{u}{v}$$

Wow. I can't rattle that off, but I can say it'll be something involving 4 additions ($$$dx$$$, $$$dy$$$, $$$du$$$ and $$$dv$$$). Guess the shape of a derivative, even if you don't know the exact description.

Why does this work? Well, suppose we had a change that was influenced by both $$$da$$$ and $$$db$$$, such as $$$15 \cdot da \cdot db$$$ -- that'd be our instrument interfering with itself!

Only direct changes on a single variable's are counted (such as $$$3 da$$$ or $$$12 db$$$), and "changes on changes" like $$$15 \cdot da \cdot db $$$ are ignored.

Dimensional Intuition

Remember that derivatives are a fancier form of division. What happens when we make a division like $$$\frac{x^3}{x}$$$? We divide volume by length, and get area (one dimension down).

What happens when we do $$$\frac{d}{dx} x^3$$$? You might not know yet, but you can bet we'll be dropping a dimension.

Dimensions Example Description
3 $$x^3$$ Volume (cubic growth)
2 $$x^2$$ Area (square growth)
1 $$x$$ Length (linear growth)
0 $$c$$ Constant (no change)
-1 $$\frac{1}{x}$$ Inverse length ("per length")
-2 $$\frac{1}{x^2}$$ Inverse area ("per area")
-3 $$\frac{1}{x^3}$$ Inverse volume ("per volume")

When we divide or take a derivative, we drop a dimension and hop down the table. Volume is built from area (slices $$$dx$$$ thick), area is built from length ($$$dx$$$ wide).

A constant value, like 3, has no dimension in the following sense: it never produces a set of slices. There will never be a jump to the next value. Once we have a constant value, we get "stuck" on the table because the 0 pattern always produces another 0 pattern (volume to area to lines to constant to zero to zero...).

We can have negative dimensions as well: "per length", "per area", "per volume", etc. Derivatives still decrease the dimension, so when seeing $$$\frac{1}{x}$$$, we know the derivative will resemble $$$\frac{1}{x^2}$$$ as the dimension drops a level.

An important caveat: Calculus only cares about quantities, not their dimension. The equations will happily combine $$$x$$$ and $$$x^2$$$, even though we know you can't mix length with area. Units add a level of meaning from outside the equation, that help keep things organized and warn us if we've gone awry (if you differentiate area and get volume, you know something went wrong).

Thinking With Dimensions

You can think about the dimension of a derivative without digging into a specific formula. In the course announcement, we had the following scenario:

We can crunch through the formula, but think higher-level. Because circumference is a 1-d line, its reaction to change (the derivative) will be a constant. No matter the current size, the circumference will change the same amount with every push. So, the extra string needed is the same for both! (About 6.28 inches per inch of radius increase).

Now, suppose we were painting the sphere instead of putting a string around it. Ah, well, area is squared, therefore the derivative is a dimension lower (linear). If we have a 5-inch and 10-inch sphere, and make them 1-inch bigger each, the larger sphere will require double the extra paint.

Questions

Let's think about the derivative of $$$x^3$$$, a growing cube.

1) What dimension should the derivative of $$$x^3$$$ have?

2) How many viewpoints should $$$x^3 = x \cdot x \cdot x$$$ involve?

3) Have a guess for the derivative? Does it match with how you'd imagine a cube to grow?

Get Free Lessons And Updates

Join 250k monthly readers and Learn Right, Not Rote.

Class Discussion

Guided class discussions are available in the complete edition.